Data study
We asked ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude 96 questions UK customers ask before they buy or hire. Trustpilot was the site they linked to most, six in ten links went to businesses' own websites, and nine in ten cited sites were missing from Google's top ten.
We asked ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude 96 questions UK customers ask before they buy or hire, from "where can I buy a water storage tank" to "good family solicitor in Leeds". Trustpilot was the site they linked to most, and nine in ten of the sites they cited were missing from Google's top ten for the same question.
Earlier this month we wrote that before paying for AI visibility, you should check which sites AI assistants cite, and said we would run that check ourselves across a panel of UK questions. These are the results.
The questions cover twelve sectors: golf equipment, jewellery and watches, coffee and kitchen, furniture, fashion, trade and industrial supplies, legal services, accountants, marketing and web agencies, home trades, removals and storage, and cars. Each one is phrased the way people type into a chat app when they want a recommendation. Between them the four assistants gave 384 answers and linked to 1,286 different websites.
Trustpilot, Reddit and Which? top the list
Trustpilot appeared as a source in 51 of the 384 answers, about one in eight. Reddit came second, though 27 of its 31 links came from Gemini. Which?, the consumer group, was third. Trustpilot and Which? were both cited by all four assistants.
| Site | What it is | Answers citing it | Share of all 384 answers |
|---|---|---|---|
| trustpilot.com | Review platform | 51 | 13.3% |
| reddit.com | Forum | 31 | 8.1% |
| which.co.uk | Consumer publisher | 23 | 6.0% |
| checkatrade.com | Trades directory | 12 | 3.1% |
| clutch.co | Agency directory | 10 | 2.6% |
| trustatrader.com | Trades directory | 10 | 2.6% |
| johnlewis.com | Retailer | 10 | 2.6% |
Below these few names the list spreads out fast. Of the 1,286 sites cited, 904 appeared in only one answer.
Most links point to businesses' own websites
We sorted every cited site by what it is. Six in ten citations went to a business's own website: a golf shop, a law firm, a storage company, an agency. Review sites and directories made up one in eight, and newspapers, magazines and buying guides about the same again.
| Type of site | Citations | Share of all 2,155 citations |
|---|---|---|
| A business's own website | 1,338 | 62.1% |
| Review site or directory | 266 | 12.3% |
| Publisher or buying guide | 254 | 11.8% |
| Official or trade body | 91 | 4.2% |
| Marketplace or big retailer | 78 | 3.6% |
| Comparison site | 68 | 3.2% |
| Forum or community | 40 | 1.9% |
A citation here means one site linked in one answer, counted once however many of its pages were linked.
The mix shifts with the question. For "where can I buy" questions, review sites and directories made up 4% of citations. For questions naming a city, such as "reliable electrician in Bristol", the share rose to 23%, and half of those answers cited at least one review site or directory.
Each assistant has its own favourites
Gemini cited Reddit in 28% of its answers and Trustpilot in 24%. Perplexity cited Trustpilot in about one answer in five. ChatGPT leaned most on Which?. Claude spread its links thinly, and no single site appeared in more than three of its answers.
| Assistant | Answers citing a site | Sites per answer that cited | Most-cited site (share of its answers) | Answers citing a review site or directory |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Perplexity | 100% | 7.2 | trustpilot.com (20.8%) | 50.0% |
| Gemini | 95.8% | 6.8 | reddit.com (28.1%) | 49.0% |
| ChatGPT | 89.6% | 5.2 | which.co.uk (10.4%) | 28.1% |
| Claude | 86.5% | 4.8 | threebestrated.co.uk (3.1%) | 21.9% |
The four seldom agreed. We looked at the 74 questions where all four cited at least one site. In only 13 of them, about one in six, did a single website appear in all four answers. On average the four assistants linked to 18 different sites for the same question.
Each sector has its own gatekeepers
The sites that matter most change from sector to sector. In home trades, 15 of the 32 answers cited Checkatrade, TrustATrader, Which? Trusted Traders, MyBuilder or Rated People. In marketing and web agencies, 12 of 32 cited Clutch, DesignRush, Sortlist, GoodFirms or The Manifest. Legal answers leaned on ReviewSolicitors, The Legal 500 and the Solicitors Regulation Authority. In retail sectors such as golf and jewellery, the shops' own websites led the list.
| Sector | Most-cited sites (answers citing them) |
|---|---|
| Golf equipment | affordablegolf.co.uk (9), golfonline.co.uk (9), moresports.com (9), clubhousegolf.co.uk (8) |
| Jewellery & watches | queensmith.co.uk (6), beaverbrooks.co.uk (5), goldsmiths.co.uk (5), watches-of-switzerland.co.uk (5) |
| Coffee & kitchen | currys.co.uk (8), which.co.uk (8), johnlewis.com (5), fixmycoffeemachine.com (4) |
| Furniture & home | trustpilot.com (7), which.co.uk (7), furniturevillage.co.uk (6), oakandmore.co.uk (5) |
| Fashion & streetwear | reddit.com (8), trustpilot.com (4), standard.co.uk (4), ethicalconsumer.org (4) |
| Trade & industrial supplies | tanks-direct.co.uk (6), thetankshop.co.uk (5), workwearexpress.com (4), trustpilot.com (4) |
| Legal services | reviewsolicitors.co.uk (8), legal500.com (7), yourlegalladder.com (6), sra.org.uk (5) |
| Accountants & finance | xero.com (7), accountingstack.co.uk (4), sleek.com (4), accountingcrunchers.com (3) |
| Marketing & web agencies | clutch.co (9), ecomone.com (6), whitehat-seo.co.uk (5), ppcgeeks.co.uk (4) |
| Home trades | checkatrade.com (10), trustatrader.com (8), fmb.org.uk (6), trustedtraders.which.co.uk (6) |
| Removals & storage | safestore.co.uk (7), trustpilot.com (6), shurgard.com (5), holdstorage.co.uk (5) |
| Cars & motoring | thecarexpert.co.uk (9), trustpilot.com (7), finder.com (6), carwow.co.uk (6) |
Nine in ten cited sites were missing from Google's top ten
We also searched every question on google.co.uk on a phone and recorded the first ten unpaid results. Across all four assistants, about nine in ten of the sites cited were absent from that top ten. The pattern held for every type of site, including the businesses themselves: 92% of the business websites the assistants cited did not rank in Google's top ten for the question.
| Assistant | Cited sites missing from Google's top ten | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Perplexity | 644 of 687 | 93.7% |
| Claude | 372 of 401 | 92.8% |
| ChatGPT | 402 of 446 | 90.1% |
| Gemini | 556 of 621 | 89.5% |
Google showed its own AI Overview on 71 of the 96 questions. We found the same gap on everyday searches in October, in our earlier look at what AI assistants cite. For buying questions it is wider.
What this means for UK businesses
Keep your review profiles current. Trustpilot was the single most-cited site, and in trades, legal and agency work the sector directories appeared in a large share of answers. Reply to reviews and keep the business details on those profiles accurate.
Find your sector's gatekeepers. Every sector had a different short list. Ask your customers' questions and note which directories, guides and review sites appear for your field, then make sure you are listed on them.
Write pages that answer the question directly. Six in ten citations went to businesses' own sites. Pages that state plainly what you sell, where you work, what it costs and who it suits give an assistant something to quote.
Check each assistant separately. The four rarely cited the same site, so a good result in one tells you little about the others.
Track AI citations alongside your rankings. Nine in ten cited sites were outside Google's top ten, so a ranking report alone will not show whether assistants recommend you.
Assistants change their answers from one asking to the next, so this is a snapshot. It still shows where the links point today, and many of those places are open to any business that asks its customers for reviews and keeps its listings up to date.

